Home
$1 =
 27.5665 RUR
-0.005
€1 =
 34.5215 RUR
+0.024
Search the Archives:
Today is Nov. 22, 2008 04:58 AM (GMT +0300) Moscow
Forum  |  Archive  |  Photo  |  Advertising  |  Subscribe  |  Search  |  PDA  |  RUS
Economics
Open Gallery...
Rolled 500- and 5000-ruble bills on a chessboard.
Photo: Pavel Solov
Other Photos
Open Gallery... Open Gallery... Open Gallery...  
Economics
Russia Leads in Inflation Amid 11 Biggest ...
Growth Continues on Stock Market
Falling Prices of Manufacturers Broke ...
The Profit Tax Is On Decrease
New Currency Policy Expensive
Readers' Opinions
You are welcome to share your opinion on the issue.
Sep. 04, 2008
E-mail  |  Home
Economic Prognosis
September is here, and Vlast weekly, as usual, offers its economic forecast for the current month. Experts will answer the following questions: What will happen with the dollar exchange rate to the ruble, how high the inflation in the Russian market will be, how the world oil prices will change, how the dollar and the euro will behave in the world currency market. First of all, let’s estimate August’s key economic event.
The key economic event is a cooling in the relations between the Russian government and foreign investors.

On the face of it, Russia has long been the foreign capital’s favorite country. No one remembers the crisis of 1997-98, LDCs have been so popular with international investors, and Russia turned out almost the most popular state. There have been numerous reasons for it: the oil Russia exports, is getting more expensive, Russia shares the first place with Saudi Arabia in terms of oil exports, Russia’s gold and currency reserves rank third in the world, the national currency exchange rate is rising, Russian stocks have grown much, the economy is on the rise. Why shouldn’t you benefit from the country’s progress?

Things went worse starting from early this year: several times the Russian stock market collapsed. However, at the end of July it was at a high level still: between 2100 and 2000 point. In August a real falling began: on August 26 the RTS index dropped under 1600 points. In other words, everyone wanted to get rid of Russian stocks.

As the hostilities in Georgia were unleashed, Russia’s stocks plunged by 6.51% - to the lowest level within 14 months; compared with the beginning of the year, the market fell by 25%. Experts only stoked the investor’s disappointment with Russian stocks commenting on the matter. For example, expert with Commerzbank Michael Ganske said, “Today’s events and their consequences will even more reduce the demand for Russian assets. We see another act of the play “How to destroy the investment history of a country which enjoyed confidence in the LDCs world”.”

The foreign investors’ disappointment at the Russian stock market was so deep that it affected other LDC markets. Their global stock index dropped by 2% sinking under the psychological mark of 1000 points – it halted at the 988-point level – the lowest index since August, 2007. As a result, the quotations of all LDCs except Russia plummeted by 20% since the beginning of 2008.

The stock investors’ sentiments told on the currency market. The exchange rates of national currencies went down too. The Russian ruble fell by 1%, the Turkish lira – by 1.25%, the South-African rand – by 3.42%.

It need be said that having lost any trust in Russia and other LDCs, the Western investors found themselves in a challenging situation. Considering those markets a profitable but a risky place to make investments in and transferring money to the US and European stock markets at the slightest danger is one thing. But considering the markets of the EDCs’ unstable (which is now happening due to the world financial crisis and recession in the USA and Europe) and believing in Russia’s finance and stock stability and finally becoming disappointed at it is quite another matter. Under such circumstances you can do nothing but invest in the gold – the whole world let you down.

In its turn, the Russian government became disappointed with the Western investors. So far Russia’s WTO ambitions have been one of the signs of Moscow’s being interested in international capital inflows. Russia showed that it wanted to be like everyone else in terms of investment attractiveness. Taking account of the high oil prices, currency stability, and an impressive economic development pace, you could say Russia wanted to outdo them all. And here August comes, and the Russian government sends a clear message – it is not committed to its WTO plans, it doesn’t seek WTO membership and is ready to renounce the agreements envisaging Russia’s concessions.

This said, the Russian government and the foreign investors managed to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Russian crisis of 1998. But things will never be the same again. Ten years ago the Russian budget badly needed foreign money, now it doesn’t. At that time Russia was an insolvent debtor. Now it is more than solvent. At that time the world oil prices were very low. Now, regardless of the fall in July-August, they are extremely high. Any sort of tensions in international relations will make them soar.

   &
1. What will happen with the ruble exchange rate?

In our forecast for August we pointed out that this month the Central Bank will pursue its policy of the strong national currency, so the dollar won’t fall under 23.6 rubles. But we underestimated the disappointment of the foreign investors at Russia: on August 28 the official dollar exchange rate was 24.6 rubles.

It’s not that the Central Bank ceased to pursue its policy of the strong national currency. It still doesn’t want to be accused of failing the Russian anti-inflationary plan. And, to combat the inflation, it’s necessary to let the ruble get stronger, according to the Russian government (and the IMF too). More to the point, the Central Bank least wants Russia to have a currency instability coupled with its utter prices instability.

In truth, with Russian stocks plummeting and funds flowing out from the stock market, the Central Bank doesn’t want those becoming disappointed in Russia (and the Russian ruble) get dollars at a cheap. At the same time, the Central Bank didn’t let the exchange rate go down showing that it has enough currency reserves to launch dollar interventions to back the ruble’s exchange rate. So, the ruble was both strong and controlled in August.

Our forecast: In September the Central bank will continue demonstrating that it controls the dollar exchange rate, which won’t exceed the 25-ruble mark.

2. What will happen with pries in Russia?

As we predicted in our forecast for August, despite the fact that prices didn’t grow in July during a week, the inflation in August won’t be zero, although it will be quite low. The forecast was correct: By August 25 the growth of consumer prices was 0.2% compared with the beginning of the month.

So, prices have increased by 9.5% since the beginning of the year. Taking into consideration that the new official inflation prognosis is 11.8% and there is four months left, the inflation is to be under 2.3%. It’ll be very difficult to achieve it.

The government reiterates that the control of the consumer prices growth is the key objective of the economic policy. To reach it, it is ready to apply all possible measures, including those administrative. Nevertheless, businessmen won’t give it up either. They have already got used to prices going up. Why should they stop increasing them? Moreover, you could not perceive the country flourishing in August: the Russian stock market fell, the dollar exchange rate grew. You are virtually made to increase prices in such a nervous atmosphere. Even more so you can refer to the foreign currency becoming more expensive and apply this argument both to foreign and domestic goods. The sentiments of Russian consumers also play in the hand of the prices growth: people will always spend money on something.

Our prognosis: Regardless of the government’s resolute statements, the inflation inertia is so that in September the growth of consumer prices will be over 0.5%.

3. What will happen with the world oil prices?

In our prognosis for August we pointed out that the speculators in the world oil market will keep on “having fun” playing for the rise and for the fall, but the price won’t be over $140 per barrel. The forecast was correct. In August prices dropped mainly. The retreat to the record $147 per barrel, which was reached on July 11, continued. However, by the end of the month prices started growing sharply – by August 27 they had hit the $120 mark.

There was a major reason for the increase in prices – fears of the Gustav hurricane in the Gulf of Mexico. Indeed, the season of hurricanes is close, and brokers are taking advantage of it. Still, they can use non-natural factors to play for the rise: there is military and political instability in the world.

On the other hand, purely economic circumstances dispose to playing for the fall. The obvious recession in the USA and in the Euro-zone, which turns into stagnation, ensues reduction in demand for oil. The dollar doesn’t appear that weak, and oil producers and speculators have got accustomed to explaining the growth in oil prices with the dollar’s getting cheaper and vice versa.

All in all, speculators have a plenty of opportunities to do whatever they want. But it is clear that investment and pension funds, which are the key elements of the modern oil market, are not going to take the invested money away from this market, and they will want to play for the rise.

Our forecast: Investment and pension funds would like to avoid a further rapid decrease in oil prices, so, in September it will cost more than $110 per barrel.

4. What will happen with the dollar exchange rate?

We predicted that in August speculators will get tired of July’s play (when the euro first got very expensive and then started falling quickly), and in August the euro won’t be under $1.54. But we underestimated the speculators; they didn’t get tired, and the dollar was getting stronger in August. On August 28, you could get $1.48 for the European currency bill.

Speculators paid much attention to the world oil prices primarily. In fact, they are guided b y the belief that the dollar exchange rate and the oil price move in opposite directions. They have different explanations of this dependence. For example, the following: oil exporters get so many dollars when prices grow at a record pace that they try to diversify their currency reserves and but euros. Or you can hear that, with the dollar falling, speculators don’t know what to play for and buy up oil futures causing an increase in their price. But, whatever the explanation, it’s the reality.

Speculators used another favorite theory of theirs: currencies’ exchange rates must be determined by the difference in interest rates in different countries. Presuming that because of the unfavorable situation in the Euro-zone and in Great Britain the Central Banks of those countries would have to lower the interest rates to encourage business activity, speculators started selling euros and pounds purchasing dollars instead.

Our forecast: In September speculators will least expect interest rates lowering in the Euro-zone and a fall in oil prices, so, the euro will cost more than $1.45.


Sergey Minayev

All the Article in Russian as of Sep. 01, 2008

E-mail  |  Home

Forum  |  Archives  |   Photo  |  About Us  |  Editorial  |  E-Editorial  |  Advertising  |  Subscribe  |  Subscribe to Printed Editions  |  Contact Us  |  RSS
© 1991-2008 ZAO "Kommersant. Publishing House". All rights reserved.